My 2 year old just flushed her pacifier down the toilet?

I have two extras somewhere. . .but maybe I should use this opportunity to break the habit. Is "I'm sorry, you flushed paci down the toilet, we don't have it anymore. All gone, no more paci." too cruel? She usually only has it at nap time and before bed. She will freak out if she doesn't have it tonight though. Thoughts?